maandag 29 april 2019

A question for Dubai 2020


Lately, I’ve briefly visited Dubai and a few other places in the United Arab Emirates (UAE).  As reported elsewhere, I quite enjoyed the visit, much appreciated the very generous welcome by the local host of the next EV venture, and of course, just having a look in a new country (at least for me) is always a neat thing to do. So, in general, I think the next global HSR symposium in Dubai should be a great event, and I’m already looking forward to it. In many ways, Dubai is a very appealing and fitting location for a global HPSR symposium in 2020, also with a view on the current global health & HPSR challenges.

Still, after the visit I remained with one question, even if I know it's early days for "Dubai 2020".  The current draft of the symposium programme looks fairly ‘political’, and obviously, I find this more than appropriate, given our rather political times (see for example ‘Extinction rebellion’ (in the ongoing battle against climate change), the increasing polarization in many countries, after we saw TINA (“centre-right”) policies for too long, …), and the fact that health has always been (at least partly) political (and now even more than ever, some would argue). Still, I somewhat wonder how ‘cutting edge’ discussion on all these political issues will take place in Dubai, and especially how social media ‘coverage’ (including ‘noise’) of these (more political) symposium discussions will go. It’s a rather peculiar environment, certainly when it comes to social media. I certainly don't envy the job of the organizers & Communications people in this respect.

I’m sure the HSG Board has already deeply reflected on this issue, and there’ll likely be some recommendations and guidelines for symposium participants in the months to come, but I’m afraid at least some participants will have to thread a thin line between criticizing injustices in the world (including in “global health” itself) and “speaking truth to power” on the one hand, and breaking the laws of UAE and/or “not respecting” the local culture, on the other, certainly in the interconnected world we live in. At the same time, if we do manage to criticize some issues (within certain limits, obviously), that could push the UAE (and our own countries’ involvement in some issues) towards progress, and Leaving No One Behind in the medium term.  It will be about finding a good balance, is my sense, but that's easier said than done.

A few examples of possible controversies:

·     *    Patriarchy: although Dubai is fairly open for (and relaxed about) people from around the globe (including their various ways of clothing), and progress is gradually being made, patriarchy is (still) everywhere in the country. If that already bothers me ( a fairly average white male), I can only imagine how certain communities within the HPSR family will react. Two personal examples, for what they’re worth: I personally draw the line at niqabs, when it comes to clothing (anybody who sincerely believes that women should cover their face in public in the 21st century, when their husband is not doing the same, can try and come convince me), and also seeing the wisdom of invariably male rulers displayed on billboards isn’t exactly my idea of a political system fit for the 21st century. I know both examples are potential minefields to wade into, and my opinion is certainly only one person’s opinion, no more - even a Western middle-aged male’s, which might disqualify me altogether from even having an opinion worth listening to on the first issue, I’m aware. But the strong patriarchy is an issue, nevertheless, I think, certainly in times where we think SDG5 (on gender equality) is crucial for the entire SDG agenda, and gender equity is rising on the global health agenda and in global health governance, for very good reasons by the way. How will we discuss this at the Dubai symposium, while also trying to respect local sensitivities and culture? I hope this doesn’t mean we’ll have to frame everything in politically correct “jargon” on social media.   

·      *   Migration & health:  we came across (many) taxi drivers who work 12 hours a day, day after day (and even one who worked 20 hours a day, 7/7 !). I totally understand they want to earn hard cash, and that they consider this a ‘win-win’ situation in most cases…  But still, one would like to discuss this full-on, within SDG 8 (‘decent work & economic growth’), while certainly also acknowledging some of the progress made in recent years (for example, quite a few of them had health insurance now). Again, if you discuss this in-depth during sessions, what will be the guidelines for social media?

·     *    More tricky still, how about discussing the ‘causes of the causes’, the roots of some of the big migration waves, crises and ‘fragile & conflict affected settings’ in recent years? For example, hard to avoid weapons & weapons trade (including, clearly, Western countries’ own involvement in these) in this discussion, in, say, Syria, Yemen, …

·     *    Final example: global taxation. Just a personal example again: in a UHC era whereby countries agree, at least in rhetoric, more and more on the importance of public financing for health, last year I came across an article on how at least some Belgian companies seem “fairly happy” with the taxation rules in Dubai. Again, (global tax justice) progress might be on the horizon (at least if I believe the ‘glass half full’ person in me), but meanwhile, will we be able to really discuss this issue in-depth, including on social media?


These were just a few random examples, but I’m curious how HSG will handle all this next year. It will certainly be a difficult equilibrium to find.  But I’m confident we can pull it off, if we want. After all, at previous symposia (say, Cape Town, Vancouver, Liverpool, …) many of the local challenges also provided the backdrop for insightful and hardhitting discussions in various sessions at the symposium, including on social media.


dinsdag 19 maart 2019

Is global health truly “a lost cause”?


In recent weeks, several people dwelled on the question whether ‘global health has lost it’ (although not necessarily putting it in these terms). A very brief overview here, with some of my own comments & feedback added.

1.  In an Offline contribution from a few weeks ago, Lancet editor-in-chief Richard Horton started from Kishore Mahbubani’s book, “Has the West lost it?”, and then seemed to answer a similar question, “Has global health lost it?”, affirmatively.

I’m not a big fan of Mahbubani’s discourse, to be honest, it smacks a bit too much of geopolitical power shift thinking (while not seeming to question this “power” much), he’s a bit too fond of the “Singapore model” to my taste, and in general too close to Davos power corridors as well. I also have my doubts on the sustainability of assessments like “Paradoxically, while many western populations are losing confidence in their political systems, Asian levels of trust in government are increasing”. I’ll never forget the cynical grin on a Chinese friend’s face when we passed the “warped” shape of the CCTV building in Beijing, mumbling something like “a very neat symbol for the governance in my country’.

Nevertheless, it’s hard to argue with (most of) the conclusions Hortons draws for global health, based on his reading of Mahbubani’s book:

(quoted here in full)

“What does Mahbubani's analysis mean for global health? First, western global health elites must reappraise their history. They must reflect on, understand, and come to terms with their colonial legacies, the consequences of their wars, and the adverse effects of their political and economic dominance. Second, based on that historical reappraisal, western approaches to global health must be radically rethought. We should be preparing for a near future in which centres of economic, political, and people power will shift from the West to the Rest. Third, strong and effective multilateral institutions will become increasingly important for managing this new world. The West should be investing in multilateral health institutions, ensuring that their leadership and governance is truly international (which currently it is not). Fourth, the hegemony of the white Anglo-American male in global health must come to an end. Finally, global health initiatives, processes, and events must prioritise voices outside the traditionally dominant western elites. It is painful to be confronted with the truth about yourself. It is painful to give up power and privilege. But for all those working in global health, it's time we listened to Mahbubani. Because global health has indeed truly lost it.”

2.  When responding to the question ‘Has global health lost it’, Andrew Harmer nailed it, from another perspective, with a simple tweet:

“As long as it remains oblivious to the economic restructure required to avert #ClimateBreakdown, then yes. GDP cannot continue as the default measure of economic 'progress'!”

I had put my hopes on the planetary health paradigm to do exactly that, but for the time being, the “new paradigm” is not really living up to my expectations. The Planetary Health Alliance, for example, doesn’t really seem to seriously consider thinking “beyond capitalism”, even if our times truly and urgently need it.  Why that is the case probably requires a blog in itself.

3.  In an  IHP blog from some weeks ago, Rachel Thompson, after attending this year’s PMAC conference in Bangkok, dwelled on the political economy of global health.

In one particular paragraph, she put it like this:

“…Global Health – as a product of a certain time and place – cannot be taken out of the global political (and economic system) that created it. Public Health is here to stay, Global Health may not have the same longevity. …”

In short, she considers Global Health as part of the neoliberal global political economy, and says that as such, Global Health risks to get ‘left behind’ itself, as the times (and the fight for global justice) are changing.

Some more quotes:

“The global political economy is one dominated by the ideology of Neoliberalism, which places the individual and free-market at the centre. As I suggest above, Global Health is a product of the Neoliberal era (Public Health is not). … “

“…Once we understand Global Health as inseparable from Neoliberalism, we can begin to get to the root causes of why so much of the world are being “left behind” from global goals. To ignore its influence is to deceive ourselves and the people we are trying to serve….”

“Once we understand Global Health as part of a system that has increased global inequalities and inequities, it seems strange to expect it to do the opposite – to “reduce inequities” e.g. as part of Agenda 2030’s leave no one behind pledge. …”

Global Health is great for measuring things and improving health security; it is not necessarily the right place for people who want to tackle injustice, and change the world in the many ways it so urgently needs changing.

While I don’t fully agree with her – I don’t think Global Health is inseparable from Neoliberalism, although there’s indeed quite some overlap – it’s true that a big chunk of global health ‘power’ feels more comfortable with what I would call the ‘more progressive faces’ of neoliberalism, among others Macron and Bloomberg in this era, and Gates of course for almost 20 years now. Power in Global health is a lot less fond of the more radical language used by Sanders, Corbyn, AOC, Warren, …   

In general, Global Health also is a bit too close to the world’s leaders and their discourse (see the focus on the G7, G20, European leaders, Davos …), with of course the way ‘Replenishments’ are set up, as a key example. I wonder whether, for example, at the upcoming Global Fund replenishment, anything will be said about the yellow vests movement at all… to not ruin Macron’s “party”.  

4.  Global Health ‘power’ is certainly a lot less enchanted with the even more radical (and now increasingly violent) behavior and concerns of bottom-up movements like the yellow vests in France. Sometimes, global health even gives me the impression to be as baffled as Emmanuel Macron these days versus this movement of citizens (not unlike when Trump was elected or the Brexit vote turned out ‘odd’).

That brings me to another point where global health has failed in recent decades, and certainly since the global financial crisis. Global health has not paid enough attention to the broken social contracts in countries in the North between too many citizens and their government. With a retreating state, and more difficult access to public services, due to 30 years of neoliberalism, more and more people feel the system isn’t working for them (anymore).

Global health has not sufficiently paid attention, for a number of reasons (see also (3)), to the increasing number of citizens in the North who feel ‘left behind’, probably one being the fact that the field traditionally tends to focus on what ‘wealthy countries’ do in LMICs  (in spite of all the talk of transnational global global health challenges, and the “universal” SDG era). Perhaps global health was a bit too focused on ODA figures to notice what was happening inside Northern countries, in terms of rising within-country inequality? With all the polarization and even sheer hatred that comes with that, as we could, sadly, again see, on the streets of Paris, last Saturday.

5.  One of the more recent contributions doesn’t really frame things as bluntly as the others for global health, rather, it says Global health should focus in the future more on democratic governance. I’m talking here of course of the recent study in the Lancet by T Bollyky et al.   

Democratization seems to have all kinds of good impacts on public health, certainly on a number of NCDs. Presumably, as democracy comes with more attention for rights and accountability.

For the time being, I won’t dwell much on this very interesting study. Before I make up my mind on it, I’ll first await the no doubt many Letters in the Lancet to comment on it, in terms of the methodology but also the broader implications & messages : )

As for the methodology, I’m “in shock and awe” for this sort of thing, knowing all too well that the Dieleman’s of this world are way smarter than myself. My quantitative days are long gone (about 20 years in fact), not to mention my fast aging/pre-demented brain, but still, I vaguely remember this sort of research is always a bit tricky. For example, when it comes to constructing indexes, or in terms of ‘what do you compare with what?’

Also, what do national democracies (and even transitions) really “mean”, in this day and time, when at least a considerable chunk of the population feel their country is put in a ‘golden straitjacket’ (cfr. Rodrik); democratic transitions in the EU are probably quite different from ‘stand-alone’ democratic transitions;  and other ordinary citizens in "democracies", say the yellow vests, argue they can say pretty much anything in their country but that nobody (certainly not the elites) listen(s).  In any case, as I am not qualified, I hope the David Roodmans of this world will take a good look at the paper, and then share the good, bad & ugly in it, from a methodological point of view. 

As for one of the broader messages of the paper, I have my doubts, though.

I quote: “When enforced by free and fair elections, democracies are more likely than autocracies to lead to health gains for causes of mortality (eg, cardiovascular diseases and transport injuries) that have not been heavily targeted by foreign aid and require health-care delivery infrastructure. International health agencies and donors might increasingly need to consider the implications of regime type in their efforts to maximise health gains, particularly in the context of ageing populations and the growing burden of non-communicable diseases.”

Especially the part in bold I find tricky, certainly in a changed world. I’m more in favour of global health going wherever the needs are greatest, regardless of regime type, but then not shying away from saying a few ‘politically incorrect things’ whenever invited, whether it’s in Kagame’s Rwanda or Putin’s Russia.

Conclusion

My own take on the question ‘has global health lost it’ is, as you might have expected, a combination of most of the above. I don’t think it’s a lost cause, yet, but global health has to evolve in the SDG health & planetary health era, and urgently so. Otherwise, it will indeed – to paraphrase Christine Lagarde on the very much needed global tax reform, last week – soon become ‘out of date’.  

By way of thought experiment, if one would describe how “global health” works to Greta “I don’t do compromises” Thunberg, I guess she’d have rather harsh words for the field. But I will leave that task up to her compatriot Kent Buse : )

Having said that, there’s no denying that global health has done (and does) an enormous amount of good, just in terms of millions of lived saved, for example.

And already it’s changing, see for example – in the areas listed by Horton (need for more diverse voices) – the decoloniality debate, Women in Global Health, …   

Probably too slowly, though.




PS: I learnt by now that Kent Buse is in fact Canadian, not Swedish. #allapologies :)

dinsdag 12 februari 2019

The Green New Deal is the battle of our age


It’s becoming increasingly clear that the ‘Green New Deal’ should be the rallying cry for global health & planetary health communities, at least if you haven’t given up on ‘Global Health’ as a force for the better in this world.

The Green New Deal is an agenda fit for the SDG health & planetary health eras. In fact, it’s probably the only agenda fit for our times in which humanity, as Owen Jones put it today in a Guardian op-ed, faces an existential risk, with the risk of overall systemic collapse fast becoming a mainstream topic in scientific journals & publications.

It’s an agenda that connects the dots, as Ann Pettifor already stressed, earlier this week.

“…The Green New Deal demands major structural (governmental and inter-governmental) changes (not just behavioural change) in our approach to the ecosystem. In addition, and as in the 1930s, such change to be driven by radical structural transformation of the finance sector, and the economy. It was developed on the understanding that finance, the economy and the ecosystem are all tightly bound together. Protecting and restoring the ecosystem to balance cannot be tackled effectively without transformation of the other sectors. Financing the transformation of the economy away from its dependence on fossil fuels cannot be achieved without a transformation of the finance sector.”

Owen Jones again: “The magic of the Green New Deal is it argues that confronting the environmental crises cannot be separated from social and economic justice: its other proposals include guaranteeing every American a job with decent wages and conditions, as well as high-quality healthcare, affordable housing and economic security.”   The same is true, at a global level.

It’ll be the Green New Deal, in the coming years and decades, or chaos and systemic collapse. That other ‘systemic agenda for the SDG era’, i.e. “going from billions to trillions’, with plutocrats, Big Finance and the global corporate sector still firmly in control, isn’t going very well, last time I checked. One of the main protagonists even left the Titanic.

Before you go away, feeling this is all too utopian, it’s good to keep in mind Rutger Bregman’s assesmment of our changing times last week, an accurate perception in my opinion, at least in the North:

“I’m 30 years old. I’ve been writing for seven or eight years now. And never before have I had such a strong feeling that the zeitgeist is really shifting and now you can talk about things that were simply not possible just a couple of years ago. It seems like the window of what is politically possible is just opening up, or that what they call the Overton window is shifting. Ideas, according to theory that originated with political scientist Joseph Overton, are seen as somehow acceptable to discuss at a certain creative time, and the real political challenge is to move the window….”

So yes, the replenishment of the Global Fund and other global health Funds is (very) important, given the number of lives at stake, but somehow, ‘Replenishments’ sound so MDG- (and dare I say, neoliberal era-like).  We live in different times now, and it’s time Global Health adjusts. I have a hunch that if we all, instead, rallied behind the Green New Deal, nationally and globally, Replenishments of Global Public Goods would almost overnight also become so much easier. And many more lives would be saved as a result.

I leave you with a nice quote. As a middle-aged person put it on Twitter, earlier this week: “When I grow up, I want to be like Greta Thunberg.”    I’m sure you know the feeling. We need to find back our inner Thunberg. We all had it, when we were young kids.

It’s time to bring her back.

zondag 27 januari 2019

The Global Fund: no longer a frontrunner in the SDG era (and what to do about it)


It’s been a while since the Global Fund was considered a splendid innovation allowing global health funding to go from millions to billions, at the start of the MDG era. So it’s sad (though perhaps not entirely surprising) to see that the Global Fund leadership doesn’t recognize times have changed.

I was reading Peter Sands’ case, this morning in a Stat  Op-Ed, in which he (rightly) claims the private sector should shoulder some of the responsibility for improving global health, but fails to draw the obvious conclusion.  

I understand his argument that the private sector can bring quite some expertise and resources, in a number of areas (and so global health would indeed be dumb not to make use of them).

On “SDG era / holistic global health thinking”     (see for example the rather “interesting” relationship of the GF with Big Alcohol – till recently? - and Big Soda), the Global Fund is certainly not a trailblazer anymore (as has been pointed out in detail by many, elsewhere), with superior service delivery expertise as one of the weak excuses used for these sorts of partnerships. Let’s hope that with time, the GF will become wiser in this area.

But here I’d like to focus on the fact that Sands fails to see the writing on the wall, in many countries, in terms of mobilizing resources. He still seems to think corporate “peanuts” will suffice: “  While in Davos, I called on private sector leaders to mobilize at least $1 billion (i.e. out of 14 Billion) of that target.” 

It’s worth quoting his final paragraph in full:

“…we also need private sector leadership in mobilizing financial resources. The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation is by far the largest of the private foundations supporting the Global Fund, and (RED) has raised more than $600 million for its fight against AIDS in Africa. Business leaders should heed Bill Gates’ words that the foundation’s investments in global health funds (including Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance; the Global Fund; and the Global Polio Eradication Initiative; [Gates also added the GFF]) are “the best investments that Melinda and I have made in the past 20 years, and they are some of the best investments the world can make in the years ahead.” Gates said these investments have generated returns of 20 times the amount invested….”

So why, on earth, do Peter Sands (and also Bill Gates, for that matter) then not draw the obvious conclusion? That it’s high time, for (global health) public-private partnerships to mobilize a big part of the money via taxing of the private (and global finance) sector? Put differently, let’s take ‘partnerships' to the next level 😊.

I heard Sands say, in response to a similar quote from Sania Nishtar, at the Davos session on ‘financial innovation for global health’ that ‘tax’ is “actually his favourite innovation”. Why not put this, explicitly, on the table then, also at global level (now, Sands & others mainly seem to consider tax key for domestic revenue mobilizing), for global corporations? As in: taxing the winners of globalization, and so let them really be ‘stakeholders’ in/towards a better future, and really “shoulder some of the responsibility for improving global health”.

A suggestion for the replenishment of the Big Global Health Funds (& then one more)


The same goes for Bill Gates. If, as he rightly states, replenishment of these Big Four Funds is very important to prevent  global health (outcomes) backsliding in the years to come, why not seize the current momentum in countries like the US (with AOC’s tax proposal) or many European countries, where many citizens understand damned well (and totally agree with) Oxfam’s  third key message in its annual Davos report,   to “End the under-taxation of rich individuals and corporations. Tax wealth and capital at fairer levels. Stop the race to the bottom on personal income and corporate taxes. Eliminate tax avoidance and evasion by corporates and the super-rich. Agree a new set of global rules and institutions to fundamentally redesign the tax system to make it fair, with developing countries having an equal seat at the table.’”

Jeffrey Sachs & others made an interesting suggestion in this regard, a few weeks ago, ahead of the Global Fund Replenishment – “hundreds of the super-rich could easily pledge $5 billion per year for the period 2020-2022”.  But it’s not going far enough (as he linked it to the Giving Pledge, and refrained from using the word ‘tax’, still a “toxic” term in Davos I understand). I also don’t understand why it should be limited to the GF replenishment only.

Why, instead, not explicitly, as part of the SDG 3 Global action plan, foresee taxing of multinationals ( or a similar proposal) as a way to (help) fund “the Big Four”? And of  course, WHO as well, no doubt the biggest global public health good of all?

It’s not rocket science. All global health leaders of big organizations actually believe in (more and progressive) taxing (and even Bill Gates does so, in his latest reincarnation).

The time seems certainly more than ripe. And trust me, if Global Health fails to do so in the years to come, it will suffer, funding wise and in terms of legitimacy. That would be a shame.  Conversely, global health (funding) could once again be an inspiration for other (SDG relevant) sectors.

How it needs to be worked out in detail, that’s something for (health) economists, tax experts (and lawyers), I’m not qualified 😊.

I suspect, though, that the current global health leadership is too close to Davos men & women to draw this – in my opinion, rather obvious – conclusion on “global health funding for the new SDG era”…    Let’s hope they prove me wrong in the years to come.  

dinsdag 22 januari 2019

Davos 2019: a Global Health 'Garden of Eden' no more, let alone a Planetary Health Garden of Eden


Hmm, what can I say about Davos that hasn’t been said already? Arguably, not much, after Anand Ghiridaradas has described  "MarketWorld" in extensive detail, and "Davos" is widely seen as "in decline".

Having said that, (too) many with power in global health still don’t seem to get it.   Indeed, as Stat puts it, “some of the biggest names in science and medicine are in the Swiss ski resort town of Davos this week to rub elbows with world leaders and one-percenters — and talk about the future of health care.”

So let’s try one more time.

Maybe you think I’m not very objective (and you would be right 😊), but my sense is that the annual meeting in Davos is by now fully delegitimized. Whereby in the past, western political leaders got away with the mantra ‘we need to go there to attract business to our country’, increasingly you’ll see political leaders make the same calculation as Macron - a smartass by all means - this year. Davos has become no less than “toxic” in the eyes of big parts of the population, certainly in the West.  

Moreover, Guy Standing probably has a point when he says that the ‘yellow vests’ movement is a sign that the precariat is (finally?) waking up as a class. If global (especially within-country) inequality is not dealt with substantially in the years to come, that trend will only increase. Standing already estimates the precariat in Western Europe at 40 %, and as he rightly mentions, even if that estimate is too high, many among what he calls the 'salariat' fear that their own children will be part of the 'precariat'. If these two classes were to ally, that could put a lot of pressure on political leaders in the years to come, and 'going to Davos' won't be a badge of honour anymore, to say the least.  Whether Klaus Schwab likes it or not, if political leaders stay more and more home (for good reason, in my opinion), that will jeopardize his lofty dream of a ‘multistakeholder’ platform “for the progress of the world”.

Yes,  the WEF talks all the time about inclusiveness and sustainability, and this year even more than ever before, but the ones who still believe that the Forum will be instrumental towards both key aims for the 21st century, are probably an ‘endangered species’ themselves, anno 2019 :) 

Speaking of inclusiveness, for example: does anybody among you truly believe that ‘millennials are taking over Davos”, presumably because this year they are co-chairs?  If I were a millennial, wanting to change the world, the last place I’d want to be seen is Davos. Even if I were a 'Technology Pioneer' or 'Global Shaper'.   Instead, it’s mostly in countries that political fights for a more human and sustainable global economic system will need to be fought in the years to come, and the millenial generation is indeed taking the initiative in more countries, encouragingly.  

Over to sustainability (or dare we call it, ‘planetary health’), then.  I’m probably not the only one wondering why the Davos crowd would be listening attentively to David Attenborough’s wise words, when he pointed out this morning, “Growth is going to come to an end, either suddenly or in a controlled way’ – we need to get on with practical tasks.”   No, who really matters in Davos mainly listens to the IMF Global Outlook report (which came out the day before, setting the scene for the Forum), in which the global ‘growth’ percentage was wat really mattered. Yes, Christine Lagarde might call it ‘inclusive’ growth, or use some other politically correct term, but ‘growth’ is what still turns most of the Davos participants on. The “Globalization 4.0 era” is not different in that respect from the previous ones. Making the link with post-growth thinking is clearly beyond Schwab and fans. So no, I don’t expect much ‘planetary health’ progress to come out of Davos, as everything in terms of potentially useful initiatives kickstarted there, is somehow ‘overruled’ by the persistent overall (discourse) focus on growth. Unless, of course, you believe in the fairytale of green growth, Davos will not make the planet more sustainable. The many private jets at Zürich airport probably already gave you a clue in this respect.

Global health

So there’s not much to be done in Davos for the ‘planetary health ‘community  (although I hope Greta Thunberg proves me wrong), what about the ‘global health’ community?   While I appreciate the efforts from many who try to ensure global health financing (for example, for the “4 Big Funds”) for the coming years, I wish they’d make the link with tax justice much more explicitly. The latest Oxfam report (see their third key message this year) could be an obvious entry-point for that. And I’m sure the precariat would appreciate it, if for example the Global Fund and other global public goods got at least half of their funding from corporate Fat Cats (corporations & high net-worth individuals, enormously undertaxed according to the latest Oxfam report).  But I figure Sands, Gates et al didn't mean that, with ‘Financial innovation for Global Health’, the name of their session today….  ?

As for pandemics and global health security, “à la limite” i can understand why global health big shots want to go to Davos, to make that case towards political leaders & business people from multinationals, and get some ‘result’. See for example CEPI recently. But again, why not calling for a global wealth tax to help finance all these efforts ? 

On mental health then: I appreciate the efforts done by the  Wellcome Trust   and others to get this issue on this year’s agenda, as mental health should indeed become far more important on the global agenda. Two small remarks perhaps: (1) given that many WEF participants play key roles in sustaining this - by all means, insane - global economic system, maybe Davos is indeed an appropriate place to discuss ‘mental health’ 😊  (2) On the other hand, I’m more than a bit worried that this focus on ‘mental health’ in a place like Davos will mainly tick global business boxes if it leads to even more productivity. As in: “staff who feel well will also perform better for your company!”.   ( a bit the mental health equivalent of a global health “investment case”) I, for one, doubt whether big corporations truly care about the wellbeing of their staff (see Amazon and many other examples), and for the ones that do care, they probably don’t care much about the wellbeing of the many people who can’t find good jobs in the first place.  In short, I have some doubts about the relevance of the ‘mental health at the workplace’ agenda, if it’s not soundly linked to post-growth thinking (which also includes “decent jobs for all”, as far as I am concerned). I still dream about a world whereby everybody’s contribution, one way or another, would be appreciated in the economy and society (without all of us having to fit the harsh ‘efficiency’ laws of the global neoliberal economy).  But once again, I hope I’m proved wrong and that “The Duke” and others will make a real difference in Davos on mental health.

Davos Partners


Last but not least, I invite you all to have a look at Davos’ “Partners”. It’s quite an insightful list. 
Credit where it’s due, the WEF is quite transparent about it.

Quite a few of these Partners are actually led or owned by people on that notorious Oxfam list (the 26 billionaires owning as much as half of the world’s population). But there’s more.

Besides the Gates Foundation, the Wellcome Trust and the Rockefeller Foundatino, you also find there for example: Chevron; Lukoil; Shell, Saudi Aramco (Big Oil); Goldman Sachs  (global capitalism’s 'Darth Vader') ; Facebook, Google (surveillance capitalism), Deutsche Bank (crony capitalism); PepsiCo; the Coca cola company (Big Soda)); the Volkswagen Group (remind me again, Germans, what was wrong with these guys?).

Fortunately, we read, from the WEF’s info page:

“The World Economic Forum is an independent and impartial International Organization for Public-Private Cooperation. Its objective is to improve the state of the world. It does not promote any political, commercial or personal interests, nor does it use the names of its participants for promotional purposes. The Annual Meeting aims to be open and inclusive. Transparency and public inclusion are achieved through broad international media participation, televised sessions and webcasts, and through the Forum’s millions of followers social media. …”

For some reason, I trust the assessment of Nick Hanauer, entrepreneur and venture capitalist, more.  He says in the Foreword of the Oxfam report that if we don’t get this right, “eventually the pitchforks will come out”.

So here’s my humble advice to Seth, Peter, Katja and all the other global health bigwigs in Davos:  you might want to keep these ‘pitchforks’ in mind, when dealing with the current “powers that be” in Davos in order to get global health ‘results’ 😊.   And start thinking of a different 'Theory of Change' to make global & planetary health progress in the SDG era.

maandag 17 december 2018

Narratives for global & planetary health: Where are Winston Churchill & Wynona Churchilla when you need them?


Others have no doubt noticed the similarity as well, but I only recently stumbled upon it. (No, I don’t mean a vague resemblance between Winston Churchill & Wynona Ryder 😊. )

Global health leaders (like Bill Gates) and organizations (say, GAVI or the Global Fund) typically want to portray a ‘positive message’ of progress, success (“X many lives saved”) and hope,  in order to convince global citizens, governments and donors to sustain the global health effort. Or so they hope. Till recently, and perhaps throughout the MDG era, they actually had a case, as Rosling and others have mapped – it wasn’t just the ‘global health success cartel’@work.

Along the same lines, it is often said that in the battle against climate change, a similar (largely positive) narrative and framing is needed (instead of the more familiar one of ‘doom & gloom’,  aka ‘time is running out’, ‘we have only 12 more years to get this right’ (or even less, for the Kevin Andersons among you), or ‘humanity is on a suicidal path’ (see UN SG Guterres last week)). You need to give people hope, experts emphasize, otherwise they’ll succumb to despair and cynicism. 

There’s no doubt some truth to this assessment. I myself have a blurred (some would say ‘nebulous’) view on the ideal framing for both global/planetary health, I’m not quite clear what the best framing is – it probably differs a bit depending on your target audience and the way they’re wired. Still, for most people, I’m afraid we get the “balance” in our global health & planetary health framing wrong, focusing too much on the positive and the possible “win-wins”. In disruptive times, I doubt that’s the best strategy.

Let me explain a bit more in detail.

Disruptive times require a different framing

In global health, as this is a time of so many disruptive changes (not just in global health), I wonder whether it still makes sense to mainly point towards progress, results and success (for a recent example, see GAVI’s mid-term review), if the world as we kno(/e)w it, in many cases, seems to be imploding in front of our eyes (more or less in line with the implosion of the neoliberal paradigm). True, there’s a fair amount of scaremongering on pandemics & AMR too in global health, but global health doesn’t really pay much attention to the broader/vague anxiety of many people about the future, whether due to climate change, economic & technological disruption, migration (in the less appealing cases), or a mix of these. If horrible stats are highlighted in global health (like on air pollution), the corollary global health message is always one of hope (plus “best buys” : ) ). Seems to be a conditio sine qua non in global health reports.

Whether we like it or not, however, big chunks of the populace are currently afraid about the future and angry (about a bunch of issues) nowadays, including about the fairness and/or sustainability of the economic system.  Even if the rise of the global middle class is probably undeniable (see Kharas et al), in the SDG era a global story of progress (against all odds) sounds a bit surrealistic in many ears.   Including in my ears, I have to say, and I read Lancet ‘Grand Convergence’ Commissions for a living : )

I wonder whether in times of an increasing backlash against universal human rights, we shouldn’t rather make an aggressive case for values  and even character traits (instead of focusing on global health ‘results’), even if part of public opinion isn’t very fond of some of these values for the time being. Gates’ principle, ‘Every life has equal value’, should perhaps be promoted much more aggressively by global health folks. Implicitly, that happens of course, and explicitly, maybe the UHC movement is doing that, certainly at a national level (unfortunately, not always including migrants).

But it doesn’t feel like the dominant framing, certainly not in times of global health security, at the global level. You always get the feeling that there’s a need ‘to invest’ in health, so that other goodies (economic growth, global health security, social stability, …) will follow. Like manna from heaven. Conversely, if countries fail to invest enough, then ‘global health gains’ of the past decades “risk to be reversed”, is the message. That might be true, but it’s not exactly a message that will blow away your audience. Problem is: most of these (global) messages are catered to decision makers.  Instead, they should start from the point of view of ordinary citizens, all around the globe. Many of these perhaps don’t feel like Job yet, but they worry they might end up like Job, eventually. And in the end, they are the ones who push their decision makers in a certain direction (or not).

In the battle against climate change (and, broader, for planetary health), in the same vein, perhaps we need to make much more forcefully the case for (the interests and wellbeing of) future generations (in addition to stressing the climate change/health “win-wins” of this generation, which, arguably, are also part of the necessary framing). Future generations should also count equally, in our decision making now. They clearly don’t.

Disruptive times require different leadership as well

In both cases – whether you like it or not, global health’s future is now linked to planetary health’s-, I think we also need a lot less philantro-capitalists and leaders of Bretton Woods & other OECD institutions telling us what to do, but perhaps more Winston Churchills (and female equivalents, as this is the 21st century : )) . You no doubt remember his quote at the start of WW II: “I have nothing to offer but blood, toil, tears and sweat.”   True, Churchill was an Englishman, not a “can do”/ ‘optimism is a moral duty’ American, babbling all the time about multiple “win-wins” in the battle against Dolf. And yes, no doubt he had many flaws too. But Winston didn’t mince words, came up with a bleak but honest assessment of the situation, yet, he still managed to offer a ray of hope.  That’s, in my opinion, the balance needed currently, and the sort of leadership required.

Unfortunately, for the time being, the ones claiming to be global health & planetary health champions are too much associated with the (neoliberal) model of the old times. Bloomberg & Macron, for example, lack the legitimacy to rally citizens behind them in their own countries, so how could they be global leaders?  And while I appreciate Gates’ global health commitment, he’s not the one who will lead humanity to a better, fairer and more sustainable future (although he can and does contribute). I also have zero confidence in the likes of Jim Kim & Christine Lagarde, to lead us – in time, at least – to a truly transformed economy and the new (global and national) social contract we need. These are people to lead perhaps in times when the economic system is more or less fit for the times, but not when it needs massive transformation. The disruption is there, already, but you never get the feeling that they can lead us to a fairer and more sustainable system, thinking truly out of the box.  It goes without saying that the SDG framework  – with its rather sanitized discourse on  ‘leaving no one behind’  and, surprise, surprise, ‘SDG goal X  invariably being … off track’ -  doesn’t quite cut it either, in terms of framing,  in disruptive times like ours.

On a side note, it’s remarkable that in a (still largely) neoliberal world, where ‘ambition’ seems to be the very purpose of life for individual citizens, ‘ambition’ is lacking big time at a collective level in the fight for a sustainable planet.  Instead of saying that we need more ‘ambition, ambition, ambition, ….’  on climate change in 2019 (which is not wrong), maybe we should also have a good look at what ‘ambition’ entails on an individual level, for the neoliberalized subjects we all are, to a bigger or lesser extent. Perhaps part of the answer lies there.

If this is a disruptive era, like the thirties & World War II were, or the end of the Roman empire, the beginning of the Renaissance, the kick-off of the Enlightenment, …   maybe it’d be good to acknowledge this, as the very starting point in our global health reports and advocacy?  And not just treat the current ‘hiccups’ (like Brexit, Trump, gilets jaunes, …) as some kind of bad vibes or geopolitical mosquitoes you want to swat  (“populism”, ‘fake news’ ), hoping that after some time they’ll just go away, populism will get out of vogue again, so that you can basically go on with ‘business as usual’ (while talking about ‘game changers’ every other sentence), towards hopefully a new multilateral and cosmopolitan future. Dream on.  

Most citizens know (or at least sense) now they live in a time of disruption. It’s better to take them and their feelings seriously. Disruption, by all means - as mankind knows from experience - can go both ways. Things can change for the better, but they can also go horribly wrong in the decades ahead.  And no, TINA won’t fly anymore this time. Just ask Macron – Jupiter still doesn’t fully grasp what hit him lately.

Global governance?

Yes, as these are global (governance) challenges, in a way, we would need a “global” Churchill(a). For the time being, there aren’t many Churchill(a)s around.  More Benito's, I’d say.

As future generations are not yet on the planet, perhaps it will take somebody of the next generation, like Greta Thunberg, to take the lead. Ideally, one should identify a Greta from each country, making up a young stakeholder “world committee”, a sort of “moral conscience” of future generations not yet present on the planet.  But she and her young peers will still need to be complemented by a team of real “leaders”, a bunch of Winstons & Wynonas so to speak.  By this, we don’t mean people claiming to speak, cheaply in my opinion, on behalf of ‘the Americans’ or ‘English people’ (if they routinely only represent maximum half of them), or people in which you suspect a hidden personal agenda, when they’re making grand claims about the future of the country or the planet (while dreaming about power). As this is the system that brought them to power, they are just willing to tweak the current system a bit, and will at most manage to convince half of the voters, whether it’s for a new referendum in the UK, towards a Democratic victory in elections, or to appease the ‘gilets jaunes’.

No, we need leaders whose main motivation is ‘to get the job done’: to get to a new economic system & social contract, fit for the 21st century, and sooner rather than later. Because they know it’s the right thing to do, and they have the authenticity and legitimacy to get most of their fellow citizens behind them.

Even if time is running out, I refuse to think that averting runaway climate change is a harder challenge than it was in 1940 to go after the Nazi axis of evil.  But you need leaders who feel, in their bones and veins, that the economic model is no longer fit for this century.  And who understand that it’s extremely important to also make sure that the Bransons, O’Leary’s and Bezos of this world contribute their fair share (and preferably much more than that). If we want the new social contract to work, we just can’t afford High Net-worth Individuals & multinationals continuing to freeride. That will end in utter political chaos, and probably war. If that’s not clear by now, after this series of so called ‘hiccups’, it’ll never be clear.

This is not a time for win-wins, even if there are no doubt some. Instead, it’s a time of hard choices.

Only leaders who realize this will be able to rally the masses behind them, and let them make the sacrifices needed in our times.  Let’s hope they don’t arrive on the scene too late.

PS: yes, we will also need a “moonshot” on geo-engineering. Not that I like it much, but the WWII resemblance extends to an equivalent of the Manhattan project, I’m afraid.

woensdag 28 november 2018

Global health needs to change its game in the era of populism, perhaps the main global health disruptor of our times


This week, BMJ Opinion  started a really nice discussion on global health disruptors over the past decades (with also some reflection on the times awaiting us).

Thinking slightly along the same lines, it is clear that populism is one of the key global health disruptors of our times, if not “the” disruptor. Cas Mudde wrote recently in a Guardian piece, “How populism became the concept that defines our age” which is probably not far from the truth. Ours is, among others, the era of populism. In North ànd South, by the way. And it’s here to stay, at least for the coming decade or so.

My feeling is that global health hasn’t really (fully) adjusted to the populist era yet, still hoping somehow that the good old (MDG) times of support for global responses, global public goods, with almost unstoppable global health progress, world solidarity (at least in terms of high-level rhetoric),  support for the multilateral (though US-dominated) order, … will come back sooner rather than later. If that is to happen, however, the overall analysis of populism by global health (and development) has to change, in my opinion, including how to instrumentalize (and even capitalize on) part of the current wave of populism. Some aspects, that is.

Global health versus populism 

By and large, global health currently suffers from a focus on ‘rightwing populism’ (even if some global health scholars have zoomed in on populism in general, for example in IJHPM). That’s understandable, as even populism expert Mudde emphasizes leftwing populism hasn’t really taken off (and where it has, like in Latin America, things turned rather sour; in other places, it has been crushed). But maybe the fact that global health is still dominated to some extent by the US & the UK (where they have rather disastrous experiences with right-wing populism lately, to put it mildly ) also has something to do with it?

There’s a tendency in progressive, liberal circles (which include much of global health) to focus on all the dirty tricks (by Russian hackers, Cambridge Analytics, etc) used in the Brexit referendum & Trump’s narrow victory, while a more important question is asked far less: why was the election/referendum result so close in the first place?  Another vital question, for the many global health fans of a second referendum in the UK, is also not really taken into account: what would the rest of Europe (and especially ordinary citizens) think, if, once again, a second referendum is organized (as the first one didn’t actually lead to the “desired result”)? The EU doesn’t have a good track record in this regard, as you know. This can only further boost populism (or worse) in the rest of the EU, I think. (PS: Not that I wouldn’t like the UK to remain in the EU : ) )

Part of the reason, why the results were so close in the first place, of course, has to do with some of the root causes which have also led to left-wing populism (as it’s commonly labelled, even if some of their suggestions are probably just common (fair) sense) gaining  momentum in a number of countries, in polls or even in elections, certainly in the North: a deep unease with the current economic system and how it seems to favour the powerful and wealthy. Put differently, I just refuse to think that all Trump fans and Brexit fans are hard core racists or nativists. You just don’t hàve that many nativists & hard core racists in a country. You need to have some belief in humanity.
Other reasons why global health feels uncomfortable with populism, apart from the latter’s nasty tendency to nativism, xenophobia, … (in its right-wing form), are its post-truth and fake news streak, its difficulty with ‘evidence’, (cfr: the vaccines debate). All these are understandable, and global health should of course not give in on all of these.  Not an inch, even, with exception perhaps of trying to understand why many people have trouble to believe in science these days. Just think how the latest ‘Implant’ scandal might go down in some circles.

Towards a more nuanced global health take on populism (and the precariat, while we're at it)

Still, a more nuanced understanding of populism, and its root causes, in global health (power) circles, seems a must, if we are to make further global health progress in our messy SDG/planetary health era. I don’t think, for example, that it’s wise to talk about ‘an increase in the malign influence of nationalist, nativist, and populist movements’ (cf.r one of these BMJ blogs); that sounds too much like the Chinese government when it talks of the three evil forces of ‘extremism, terrorism and separatism’ in Xinjiang and elsewhere. It’s too easy.

There are parts of populism (and certainly of the right-wing form) that should indeed be strongly condemned, but there are other aspects of the current populist wave that global health should try to understand, and even try to work with. I find the debate somewhat linked to global health’s current (reluctant) stance versus “the precariat”, a now global group of people (a new ‘class’ in the eyes of some, Guy Standing of course in the first place) which it also hasn’t really thought through, yet (although a former colleague of mine has made a great effort,  recently (in Dutch, though)).  If the insecurity of the precariat is now increasingly a global phenomenon, global health has to up its game versus this new ‘class’. After all, this is the SDG era, presumably an era for the whole planet (not just for the South).

Just like the proletariat disrupted the system in the 19th century, the precariat is already doing that in our times, as Paul Mason argued in a recent Guardian  contribution.  “At the most basic level – and this explains the rise of both the left and right opponents of neoliberalism – people understood that emotion, and with it feelings of identity, place, nation and class, could only reinsert itself into decision-making if the system were disrupted.”

And yes, the precariat can no doubt lead the world towards “paradise” or “hell”, as Standing argues in his book, but was that really any different in the 19th and 20th century for the proletariat?  The horrors of the 20th century were not just their fault, I’d say…. And their (sometimes mob-style) pressure also led to public health (sanitation, …) progress in cities, and to a welfare system in many countries after the second world war.  Why would it be any different for the precariat, once they manage to organize themselves better? Moreover, who would dare to claim that our current elites don’t lead the world to hell, via a ruthless and unsustainable economic system?

For the moment, many in global health (power circles) still sound as if we’re still in the happy (ostensibly cosmopolitan) MDG era, focusing on the ‘most vulnerable and marginalized’, the ones “left behind”, … they hardly talk about this broader rage.

Take for example these Replenishments of global health stakeholders: their causes are lofty, and extremely necessary, no doubt about it, but how do you think these sorts of High-level events (where it certainly helps to get access if you are also a Davos “regular”) go down in the eyes of the global precariat? Do you think ordinary (struggling) people, say ‘les gilets jaunes’, think they’re on the side of elites, or of the common people, or even of the ‘most vulnerable’ they never stop talking about?  Same for Macron’s Planetary health summits, I have a hunch…. Perception matters. And I’m afraid this is, deep down, about a lot more than just perception.

Another global health (power) fixture seems to be its relentless focus on “innovation”, “cost-cutting to get more value for money”, inspired as it is by philantro-capitalism and consultancy companies like McKinsey et al. rather than, say, on ‘decent work’. Now ask yourself again: what do you think the precariat, working for the likes of Amazon, Deliveroo, Uber, … might think of all this?  And can you really blame them?

Final example: global development’s current focus on “leveraging” private sector money, “to get from billions to trillions”?  (as apparently we’ve given up on properly taxing them).  It’s good most of the precariat probably don’t know about it, as this ‘leveraging stuff’ sounds downright horrible as compared to fair and progressive taxation of the private sector & multinationals. Certainly when Oxfam reports are focusing every year on our extremely unequal wealth  (of which, I’m sure, ordinary citizens are very well aware nowadays).

Global health needs to change its political strategy/preference

Global health ‘power’ intrinsically favours centre politicians, or at least politicians they consider as ‘centre’ (say, Hillary Clinton). Unfortunately, or perhaps understandably, given the perfect storm we’re in, our times are no longer very friendly versus “centre politicians”. The centre is fading fast, and you get polarization on both sides. Politicians have to choose, pretty much like the rest of us, I guess, for a certain vision on the future. For the moment, it appears right-wing parties have the momentum, but all it takes is probably a few big countries where the dice are rolling the other way, to get perhaps a different global trend. As Mason argues, and I think this would be sound advice too for global health, it’s perhaps time to put our hopes on boosting alliances between centre-left and radical left (as is the case in Spain now). The radical left (labelled sometimes as ‘left populist”) is key in crafting a narrative of hope (for the precariat) and thinking out of the box towards another future. (I know: not every Corbyn opponent will agree with this assessment : ) )   Only then, after enough (big) countries have these sorts of alliances between centre-left & radical left in place, and ordinary citizens see the real progress in their own life, and fairer societies, the global wind might blow again in a more multilateral and solidarity-oriented direction. As for systems where you only have two parties (say the US), I’d argue global health should favour more radical left candidates for the more progressive party, rather than hoping for a more central figure, who could supposedly “bridge” things between the camps (say: Bloomberg). As I said, what might sound ‘rational’ (another word for ‘centre’), from the point of view of the current system, is perhaps not radical enough with a view on the system we urgently need in the 21st century.

Instead, however, for the moment a key global health pundit is still putting his hopes on Macron, who is, let’s face it, very much a symbol of the neoliberal elite in the eyes of the precariat. Maybe that’s wrong, and maybe Macron will prove them wrong in the years to come (I certainly hope he’s smart enough to make this (necessary) switch). But for now, as things stand, it seems a highly risky strategy for global health to align with the likes of Macron, in spite of all the fancy words coming out of his mouth, also with a view on the enormous planetary health challenge that awaits us in the next decade to try to avoid further climate breakdown. A ‘just transition’, in which everybody is perceived to do his/her fair share, will be key, if that’s to be successful.  For the moment, the computer of most ordinary citizens, says ‘No’….  If they even have a computer.

For the time being, power in global health is thus doing the opposite of what it should do, as it’s still trying to get the ear of centre -right politicians. They’re for example very much framing things in terms of global health security, nowadays, as they feel the wind is blowing from the right. Unfortunately, that stance probably also further exacerbates the (harsh) anti-migration right-wing wind. Instead, global health should help push the (political) centre towards the left (instead of to the right, which happened over the past 10 years due to radical-right forces).   

On a tangential note, but not altogether different from the abovementioned assessment, global health seems at the same time rather ‘friendly’ (to put it diplomatically) versus authoritarian populists in the South  (think Modi).


To repeat, you can’t just push aside populism as a nasty movement, or hope it will just go away, with a few political victories in the US etc. It seems more than likely that it’s here to stay, at least for the coming decade and perhaps beyond. And so global health should try to analyze it clearly, and ride on the (more progressive) aspects of the rise of global populism, while distinctly refusing and rejecting the nasty part.

Perhaps one example: take the ‘commercial determinants of health’ debate. Obviously, some of the needed measures and regulation will not go down well with (many) populists, smacking off the ‘nanny state’ in their eyes. However, other aspects should be a relatively easy sell in our times, like tax justice (also for multinationals); decent work (McDonalds etc); … 

Populism & precariat require global health to make the switch to the SDG era. Urgently.

The precariat and global populism trend require global health to make the switch to the holistic SDG era, in both North and South, trying to connect all the dots (not just health related dots).  They have no choice, actually. Otherwise, the risk is that all gains made during the MDG era will have been in vain and might even be reversed, in a world more and more under ecological stress, with increasing security risks in many countries, or even downright war, …   Moreover, we will also need the (unwieldy) precariat to move towards the post-capitalist economic system we need. If not, sooner or later, we’ll all end up ‘left behind’…

PS: so while we’re waiting for that urgent global health switch to the SDG era, I hope some brilliant complexity thinker (I can think of a few colleagues…) thinks a bit through all the possible tipping points, when trying to channel some of the (often justified) anger of the precariat, while avoiding vicious feedback loops, as they will no doubt go on ‘disrupting the system’. A system, as most of us know by now, that is leading us towards hell. Just check the latest UNEP report : )