zondag 24 mei 2020

The GAVI replenishment & toxic tweets


Lately I got annoyed by a tweet Seth Berkley (CEO GAVI) sent, “Thank you @BorisJohnson, @BillGates and @melindagates for sharing your “commitment to the vital work of @Gavi and … the upcoming UK-hosted Global Vaccine Summit on June 4." I truly appreciate your commitment to the Alliance and global health security. https://bit.ly/2XgSgx5 “

It wasn’t the first time I got annoyed.  

No doubt I’m not the most unbiased person on earth when it comes to public-private partnerships, but at the same time, I have no problem whatsoever to admit that GAVI, The Vaccine Alliance is an important Global Public Good in the world “as it currently is”. So I very much hope its upcoming replenishment (4 June) will be a success, even if I’d like to see GPGs (like GAVI) to be financed in a different way, as I have explained elsewhere: by taxing the winners of globalization (and billionaires in particular), rather than through a “replenishment”.

So why do I get so annoyed then by these sorts of tweets? Well, frankly, I consider the ‘thank you, Bill’ tweets PPP CEOs’ sycophantic equivalent of dr. Tedros’ unfortunately still too common “thank you” tweets to authoritarian leaders (like Modi, Kagame, or say, the Belarus president). They are anything but smart, and in the current circumstances probably even toxic.

I notice on the GAVI governance web-page that they have one representative of civil society in their Board. Now that GAVI will, once again, be key in delivery of Covid-19 vaccines, (a vaccine (or even a few) will materialize, I bet, but not sure though to what extent it will be effective), I think it’s time to ponder greater involvement of social movements & civil society in the public-private partnership. Yes, to some extent, organisations like MSF Access play this role,  but given the ugly mood in many societies (and even uglier conspiracy theories on the likes of Gates et al), I think an organization like GAVI (and its CEO ) can no longer afford these sorts of sycophantic ‘thank you, Bill’ tweets. It smacks of Davos men & women ‘ruling the world among each other over high-level breakfasts’, and if I’m getting annoyed by them (PS: I guess I’m not the only one among global health observers, one of them called them – and I quote – a ‘freakin’ club’ ) then you can only imagine how tweets like this go down the antivaxxers crowd. And let’s face it, with a future Covid-19 vaccine probably at least a bit ‘controversial’ (in terms of impact, side effects, …), you want to be as transparent and democratic as possible.

Time to do something about it, Seth. And about greater involvement of civil society and social movements in general in GAVI. Twenty years after its launch at the World Economic forum in Davos, GAVI The Vaccine Alliance still comes across as a largely elite-led global public good. Time for a change.

maandag 6 april 2020

World Health Day - Dear global health leaders, it’s more than time for a “double message” on health care workers


Tomorrow, 7 April, it’s  World Health Day, this time with the theme ‘support nurses and midwives’. As you know, this year is also the International Year of the Nurse and Midwife. Against that backdrop, it’s more than cynical to see so many (especially) female health workers in the frontlines of the fight against Covid-19 without proper personal protective equipment (PPE).   Many are already dying or will die due to the lack of PPE.

We hear a lot of talk and rhetoric about “our health worker heroes” now, but we have clearly failed to give too many of them, both in “developed” and developing countries, proper protection. This is something our same governments  (certainly in the West) would never allow for their soldiers going to war. Just ask some of the defense ministers, used to hundreds of billion dollar- budgets.

And if they did, the soldiers would go on strike, rightly so.

I’m not a health worker myself, but I happen to have quite some health staff among my family members, both nurses and doctors. And it’s blatantly clear at this moment in which settings some of them feel well protected while others say this feels like a sick Russian roulette.

Hence, I hope that dr. Tedros and many other global health leaders, in addition to their consistent messages on health worker heroes (not wrong, clearly) also provide an important add-on: that health workers without proper PPE have the right to strike, to quit, and/or ‘stay healthy at home’.   

As long as the global  bottleneck on material is not solved (which might take weeks or more probably months), every health worker without proper PPE  should be given the choice whether he or she wants to continue, making an assessment for him/herself whether the risk is acceptable. These health workers also have families, many of them belong to risk categories themselves or have underlying health conditions. Yes, that would lead to many more innocent Covid-19 victims, but these health workers are not the ones to blame for the situation. And you can’t expect everybody to be a ‘hero’, if ‘heroism’ resembles for some ‘going to war like WW I soldiers getting out of their trenches to face machine guns”.

They need PPE. Full stop.

If not complemented this way, the rhetoric of ‘health worker heroes’ feels just like empty waffling. So I hope dr. Tedros and his team start providing this double message at their media briefings. Certainly this World Health Worker week. And while they’re at it, they can then sketch a fairer – well resourced -world for health systems & workers, and where the money can be found for that. It’s not that difficult, really. You don’t need to envisage a grand “Apollo plan” or public health “Moonshot”...

zondag 29 maart 2020

A tentative “accountability” timeline for Covid-19


  Just a start, obviously. Lots more to be said, nuances to be added, errors to be corrected, etc.

1.      Global health neoliberalism doesn’t consider it too much of a problem if WHO isn’t sufficiently resourced. PPPs should get most of the money anyhow, as they ‘get things done’, presumably. Global health’s “who’s who” are quite happy with the few billionaires (and one in particular) who help the global health agenda (or at least part of it).

2.      The rich & wealthy (including MNCs & financial sector) are undertaxed, globally, for decades already, which is part of the reason why Global Public Goods aren’t sufficiently resourced. And health systems; ànd social protection systems; ànd PPE for health staff,  …    

3.      The Theory of Change of “Power in global health” counts on “Davos schmoozing” aka “networking” to get some things done (and funded). Obviously, they just get the peanuts, even on global health security & pandemic preparedness (which should interest the ‘powers that be’ in principle the most). 

4.      Meanwhile others engage in fairytale ‘from billions to trillions’ thinking, ‘leveraging’ private capital to get to some really “innovative” global health funding. That turns out a sick joke, with the pandemic bonds saga as just one sorry example.

5.      The Chinese regime botches the first month of the Covid-19 outbreak due to the “particularities” of an authoritarian regime. At that time, perhaps the world still had a chance to avoid the worst.

6.      WHO ignores a Taiwan warning (for too long), for political reasons.

7.      Western countries are complacent, and only start getting really worried once Italy gets hit big time, not (nearly enough) when they witnessed the horror in Wuhan. Perhaps a combination of counting on a SARS-containment effect + the ‘far away’ effect?  (East Asian countries do better for the same reasons); meanwhile, too many experts still compare the Covid-19 fatality rate with annual flu fatality rates – so that also public opinion gets worried rather late.

8.      Right wing populism & free-market ideology play an additional ‘postponing’ role in some Western countries.

9.      In country after country, the neoliberal emperor really has no clothes anymore.  Again.

10.   Turns out that global health security, indeed, starts at home. Who would have thought?

11.   The most narcissistic specimen among our Western “leaders” start the scapegoating big time. They started way earlier in the process, of course, but now they're gearing up.


To be continued, i guess...


maandag 13 januari 2020

PMAC: UHC Forum 2020 - Livestreaming the event should be a no-brainer


This year’s Prince Mahidol Award Conference (PMAC) in Bangkok (28 Jan-2 Feb) focuses on accelerating progress towards UHC.  As always, the conference programme looks  rather appealing, even if it's hard to beat last year's theme on the political economy of NCDs.

There’s one downside though: I still can’t find much information on (possible) livestreaming on the website. So here’s a gentle request to the organizers: do make sure that at least for the plenary sessions appropriate measures are taken so that people from around the globe can also watch the great speeches and presentations in the Thai capital.

Also from a planetary health point of view, this should really be standard practice nowadays, in the year 2020.

It’s still a few weeks from now. Let’s just do this.  

dinsdag 9 juli 2019

Dubai 2020 symposium theme contextualization from a (middle-aged) Northern point of view


Recently the Health Systems Global (HSG) program working group for the Dubai symposium reached out to various Thematic Working Groups to find out how the 2020  Dubai theme and sub-themes  are being interpreted, understood and linked to by the HPSR community in different contexts and geographies.  As you recall, the Dubai symposium will be themed ‘Re-imagining health systems for better health and social justice’.

Here I offer just a few quick remarks/humble suggestions from my point of view, mostly pertaining to sub-theme 1 (‘engaging political forces’) and 2 (‘engaging social, economic and environmental forces’).   

First a quick clarification on what I mean by ‘my point of view’: I’m a 46-year old man from a Northern country, fan of both Greta Thunberg & Michel Houellebecq  (I suspect I’m not the only one)  :)    Also, I don’t really qualify as a health policy & systems researcher, even if I am an HSG member and have been to all global symposia so far.  

Anyway.

·      In general, first of all I hope the Dubai symposium will manage to convey a proper ‘sense of urgency’, paying plenty of attention to the major tipping points  (ecological, political, social …) that are approaching fast now (if they’re not passed already), and their impact on health policies & systems. When it comes to climate change, it would thus be good to reframe the enormous challenge ahead in terms of ‘climate breakdown’ / ‘climate emergency’….  and probably make it clearer that this presents an existential threat to humanity (with the impact you can expect on global health progress of the past decades, health systems, ...).  As for politics & power, I think the UAE are rather well placed to understand how close certain nasty tipping points really are, at this moment in time – I just read an article this morning on the UAE partly withdrawing from the war in Yemen, among others because they’re getting worried that in case of a war between US (& Saudi Arabia) and Iran, the UAE could soon find itself in the line of fire.  

So some sort of (re-)framing, like ‘Re-imagining health systems before the world is going down altogether’ ( as an Indian friend of mine quipped ), might work wonders, to convey this sense of urgency :)  

·     Linked to the above, and more in general, I hope we won’t self-censor ourselves (too much) in Dubai. I’m not referring here to the social media constraints in the UAE (an issue in itself), rather to the analysis that more and more of us know, deep down, that this capitalist system has to go, and soon. If not, we’re on the road to hell. So I hope we can really discuss post-capitalism, post-growth, etc. (and invite relevant thinkers on these discourses & paradigms), and think through what this could imply for health systems & policies  ( PS: another good reason for these sorts of debates: the many links between capitalism/imperialism and the decoloniality debate in global health). Even if some of the Big Funders of the symposium aren’t very sympathetic towards this sort of ‘alternative’/’unrealistic’ thinking.   The same goes, by the way, for discussing as much as possible the root causes of migration, fragility, … instead of (only) assessing what health systems can and should do for the victims, so that nobody is ‘left behind’.   Only if we don’t self-censor, (i.e. making statements and using framing  palatable to some of the big funders of the symposium, also trying not to offend anybody ), we can truly re-imagine health systems for better health and social justice, instead of mitigating the worst excesses of an unfair and destructive system.


·     Still on engaging political forces & power, given the location, I think it’d be lovely to zoom in on patriarchy and its impact on 'Health for All'. You have probably come across some of the recent headlines on the UAE yourself.   I’m amongst those who believe SDG 5 is absolutely crucial in the whole SDG agenda.  Apart from that, I’ll refrain from engaging in this debate, as I usually get in trouble with my progressive/liberal female colleagues on some of these issues:)

·     I also wonder to what extent the “global health community” (with its seemingly never-ending love affair with ‘partnerships’) is still in sync with how the world is developing. Not just because increasingly it’s a fight “between oligarchy and the rest of us”, as Robert Reich put it, and so it seems high time to take sides, instead of ‘partnering’ with some actors. Or at the very least require them to pay proper taxes before they can ‘partner’.  And so,  ‘Winners take all’ (by Anand Giridharadas) should perhaps be required background reading material for symposium participants, and hopefully also inspire a strong paragraph in the “Dubai statement” afterwards, on philantrocapitalism, the Corporate Private Sector & their role in global health/health systems. While I will never deny the enormous merit of Bill Gates & his foundation, current fundraising for the Global Fund Replenishment (with the ridiculous goal of getting 1 billion from the private sector) is a case in point of how unfit global health fundraising has become for our day and age. It’s time to put ‘replenishment’ cases in starkly different terms: that billionaires & MNCs should contribute to tax, globally and nationally, the way they actually should, and not freeriding like, for example, Amazon has done in its 25 years of existence.   All over the world, people are fed up with this, both on the ‘left’ and ‘right’. For the ones among you who like ‘Beyond…’ mantras: in global health, it’s more than time to go ‘Beyond Philantrocapitalism’ :)     

·     As for the current “SDG health era”: there again,  it would be good if we acknowledged that the SDGs are not just ‘off track’, but instead, in spite of all the ongoing SDG-washing (by corporate and other sectors), going absolutely nowhere (see the just released civil society Spotlight report, which argues for not just a ‘software’ update but also a ‘hardware’ update (of governance & institutions at all levels)).  And that’s even making abstraction of the current ‘disabling’ (instead of enabling ) international environment (as Jens Martens has put it, accurately, in this Spotlight report), which, I admit, doesn't help much on the SDG 2030 journey. 


Put slightly differently: it’s probably relatively easy to go to Dubai with a story on climate-smart health systems, and link it with UHC. It’s probably far more difficult to say and argue we need a post-capitalist system sooner rather than later, or else UHC and Health for All will still be distant dreams in 2050 and beyond  ( plus get Bill Gates or USAID to fund this :)). The same goes for commercial determinants of health, STAX, access to medicines,  etc. :   let’s really take all these debates “beyond capitalism”.   Even if ‘thinking beyond capitalism’ might be a bit too early still.

As it’s more than necessary. Just this week, a new report thoroughly  debunked decoupling,   highlighting “the need for the rethinking of green growth policies and to complement efficiency with sufficiency”. Focusing on countries in the ‘North’, that sounded like this:  “Policy-makers have to acknowledge the fact that addressing environmental breakdown may require a direct downscaling of economic production and consumption in the wealthiest countries.”  So yes, let’s also not refrain from making clear what the “SDG agenda” entails for our countries in the North, including the very tricky political economy (& fairness) issues around this - as the yellow vests movement has proven.

But hey, I’m just a 46-year old bloke from the North. So I’ll be more than happy to read many other takes on how the symposium theme & subthemes are interpreted and understood elsewhere in the world, from different angles.  

dinsdag 14 mei 2019

On UHC & social contracts (fit for the 21st century)


I largely agree with Thomas Schwarz (MMI) ’s assessment of the “Key Asks from the UHC movement”    – it’s a strong and powerful document, and if a 7th Ask is eventually added, in line with what Women in Global Health advocate for, it might even become stronger. However, as I was re-watching – online - the lovely session Moving Forward Together: Key Asks from the UHC Movement for the UN HLM at the Graduate Institute  (watch that gentle grin on Kickbusch’s face when Thomas almost wrecks the word ‘multi-stakeholder’ 😊), I started reflecting a bit more on some of the political economy (& causality) aspects around the notion of a social contract, certainly given the fact that UHC 2030 sees itself as a multi-stakeholder “We’re all in this Together” platform. 

The notion ‘social contract’ is mentioned in Key Ask 1 (“Ensure political leadership beyond health – Commit to achieve UHC for healthy lives and wellbeing for all at all stages, as a social contract”)) and I certainly agree with Thomas (and Kickbusch) that this notion of social contract is vital, and thus really good to have in the Key Asks.   

Broken social contracts

Nowadays, however, the starting point in this debate should perhaps be the following: in many countries, and certainly in the North, citizens have increasingly the feeling that earlier (post- WW II) social contracts are broken (or at least not in very good shape anymore). As a result, many – see Ask 2 – feel, ahum, ‘Left Behind’. Enter all the commotion in the streets and nastiness on social media, the yellow vests, populism and “political surprises” in a number of recent elections, certainly in richer countries.  

Against that backdrop, Ask 6 (Move Together: Establish multi-stakeholder mechanisms for engaging the whole of society for a healthier world)  feels a bit ambiguous, at least for me. As it’s precisely the private (corporate) sector (aka Big Business & Big Finance), that is considered a key culprit by many citizens in this breakdown of the social contract in our – until recently - neoliberal globalization era. Not the only culprit perhaps, but certainly a big one.  They are basically seen as having taking over 'the world as we know it'. You might say this is not very relevant for the ((L)MIC)countries the UHC movement is focusing on, but the SDG era is a universal agenda, and given globalization, we’re all in this together now, with often similar challenges (even if not to the same extent perhaps), and vested interests.

If UHC is first and foremost a political choice and political will key, as dr. Tedros and many others (rightly) stress, it will be absolutely essential  that the corporate sector does its part (or perhaps more accurately, starts doing its part again, in countries in the North), when it comes to building up a new social contract fit for the 21st century. If that happens, it will become so much easier to ‘trust’ the private sector in a multi-stakeholder partnership like UHC 2030, as the WEF representative advocated for during the session.

For now, however, a pretty common perception among many ordinary citizens in the world is that Big corporations, Big Finance, Big Pharma, Big Soda, Big Tech, … don’t contribute much ( certainly not according to their ability, cfr. “the strongest shoulders”) to these social contracts in countries around the globe, and even shirk their responsibilities altogether in a number of cases. This is already the case now (see above), and many citizens fear this might get even worse in the (Fourth Industrial Revolution) future.

Instead of contributing to this social contract, many of these Big Fellas are thus considered ‘freeriders’ or worse, paying a low amount of taxation, preferring “going to the moon” over ensuring decent work conditions and salaries to employees (with many even planning further automation & robotization to get rid of workers altogether in the future, at least if they can get away with it), not to mention the enormous ecological havoc they cause in the process. Others try everything in order not to have to pay sin taxes (sugar, alcohol, tobacco, …) - or STAX, if you prefer that term. The financial sector (see the financial crisis) and Big Pharma are a story in their own right, when it comes to their role in the (disrupted) social contracts in recent years.

In short, Big Corporations & Big Finance are a big reason, if not thé reason, why social contracts are broken or at least under severe pressure in many countries in the North, among others via the pathway of underfinanced public goods & sectors. As for the South, there they are probably a big reason why social contracts never were established in the first place. But I’m not well placed to dwell on that.

People sense, all around the globe, that all this ‘People Planet Profit’ talk remains mostly empty talk, even in the SDG era, the only stakeholder to which multinationals really feel accountable are their shareholders. The economic system is seen as anything but fair, globally and nationally. In these kinds of circumstances, it will not exactly be a piece of cake to build up new social contracts.

To let UHC thus play its role, as the Key Asks advocate, as part of (building) an overall ‘social contract’ between citizens and the state, we’ll first and foremost have to get big companies contribute (again) their fair share to societies, via fair taxation, decent work & salaries, etc.    In the absence of that,  the whole idea is a non-starter, in my opinion, even a fata morgana.

How about the social contract with future generations?

A last (but equally important) comment: and how about the social contract with future generations? Although the Key Asks emphasize that we aim for a ‘healthier world’, there’s not much in them that talks about a social contract with future generations, in order to make sure that they are not ‘Left Behind’. Seems like a gap that needs addressing too, before the High-Level Meeting on UHC in September starts.  In the 21st century, given our increasingly ecologically fragile world, a social contract between citizens who live now and the state no longer suffices.

To conclude: it would be good if UHC 2030 made it a bit clearer on what exactly it will take to get to such a ‘social contract’ via a strong UHC commitment. For example towards its ‘private sector constituency’ : )

maandag 29 april 2019

A question for Dubai 2020


Lately, I’ve briefly visited Dubai and a few other places in the United Arab Emirates (UAE).  As reported elsewhere, I quite enjoyed the visit, much appreciated the very generous welcome by the local host of the next EV venture, and of course, just having a look in a new country (at least for me) is always a neat thing to do. So, in general, I think the next global HSR symposium in Dubai should be a great event, and I’m already looking forward to it. In many ways, Dubai is a very appealing and fitting location for a global HPSR symposium in 2020, also with a view on the current global health & HPSR challenges.

Still, after the visit I remained with one question, even if I know it's early days for "Dubai 2020".  The current draft of the symposium programme looks fairly ‘political’, and obviously, I find this more than appropriate, given our rather political times (see for example ‘Extinction rebellion’ (in the ongoing battle against climate change), the increasing polarization in many countries, after we saw TINA (“centre-right”) policies for too long, …), and the fact that health has always been (at least partly) political (and now even more than ever, some would argue). Still, I somewhat wonder how ‘cutting edge’ discussion on all these political issues will take place in Dubai, and especially how social media ‘coverage’ (including ‘noise’) of these (more political) symposium discussions will go. It’s a rather peculiar environment, certainly when it comes to social media. I certainly don't envy the job of the organizers & Communications people in this respect.

I’m sure the HSG Board has already deeply reflected on this issue, and there’ll likely be some recommendations and guidelines for symposium participants in the months to come, but I’m afraid at least some participants will have to thread a thin line between criticizing injustices in the world (including in “global health” itself) and “speaking truth to power” on the one hand, and breaking the laws of UAE and/or “not respecting” the local culture, on the other, certainly in the interconnected world we live in. At the same time, if we do manage to criticize some issues (within certain limits, obviously), that could push the UAE (and our own countries’ involvement in some issues) towards progress, and Leaving No One Behind in the medium term.  It will be about finding a good balance, is my sense, but that's easier said than done.

A few examples of possible controversies:

·     *    Patriarchy: although Dubai is fairly open for (and relaxed about) people from around the globe (including their various ways of clothing), and progress is gradually being made, patriarchy is (still) everywhere in the country. If that already bothers me ( a fairly average white male), I can only imagine how certain communities within the HPSR family will react. Two personal examples, for what they’re worth: I personally draw the line at niqabs, when it comes to clothing (anybody who sincerely believes that women should cover their face in public in the 21st century, when their husband is not doing the same, can try and come convince me), and also seeing the wisdom of invariably male rulers displayed on billboards isn’t exactly my idea of a political system fit for the 21st century. I know both examples are potential minefields to wade into, and my opinion is certainly only one person’s opinion, no more - even a Western middle-aged male’s, which might disqualify me altogether from even having an opinion worth listening to on the first issue, I’m aware. But the strong patriarchy is an issue, nevertheless, I think, certainly in times where we think SDG5 (on gender equality) is crucial for the entire SDG agenda, and gender equity is rising on the global health agenda and in global health governance, for very good reasons by the way. How will we discuss this at the Dubai symposium, while also trying to respect local sensitivities and culture? I hope this doesn’t mean we’ll have to frame everything in politically correct “jargon” on social media.   

·      *   Migration & health:  we came across (many) taxi drivers who work 12 hours a day, day after day (and even one who worked 20 hours a day, 7/7 !). I totally understand they want to earn hard cash, and that they consider this a ‘win-win’ situation in most cases…  But still, one would like to discuss this full-on, within SDG 8 (‘decent work & economic growth’), while certainly also acknowledging some of the progress made in recent years (for example, quite a few of them had health insurance now). Again, if you discuss this in-depth during sessions, what will be the guidelines for social media?

·     *    More tricky still, how about discussing the ‘causes of the causes’, the roots of some of the big migration waves, crises and ‘fragile & conflict affected settings’ in recent years? For example, hard to avoid weapons & weapons trade (including, clearly, Western countries’ own involvement in these) in this discussion, in, say, Syria, Yemen, …

·     *    Final example: global taxation. Just a personal example again: in a UHC era whereby countries agree, at least in rhetoric, more and more on the importance of public financing for health, last year I came across an article on how at least some Belgian companies seem “fairly happy” with the taxation rules in Dubai. Again, (global tax justice) progress might be on the horizon (at least if I believe the ‘glass half full’ person in me), but meanwhile, will we be able to really discuss this issue in-depth, including on social media?


These were just a few random examples, but I’m curious how HSG will handle all this next year. It will certainly be a difficult equilibrium to find.  But I’m confident we can pull it off, if we want. After all, at previous symposia (say, Cape Town, Vancouver, Liverpool, …) many of the local challenges also provided the backdrop for insightful and hardhitting discussions in various sessions at the symposium, including on social media.